Diddy’s sex trafficking charges: Despite media coverage, what took so long?
Fox News analyst Kat Timpf joins 'MediaBuzz' to discuss her take on the Sean "Diddy" Combs' indictment and what 'changed everything' in the federal case.
Sean "Diddy" Combs' prospective jurors were questioned about Mike Myers, beliefs regarding infidelity and their taste in music as the defense and prosecution set out to narrow down the potential pool to 12.
Diddy's jury selection continued Tuesday with voir dire, the questioning of potential jurors to assess their ability to remain impartial upon hearing various types of evidence.
Judge Arun Subramanian instructed the lawyers that jury selection would "continue for the next few days," with the trial scheduled to begin Monday. He gave jurors instructions "not to discuss case or read about it. Delete news alerts. Don’t allow anyone to speak to you."
Combs appeared anxious on the opening day of jury selection. After requesting a bathroom break at one point, he told the judge, "I'm a little nervous today." Diddy's team and the prosecution were allotted five days to seat the jury with opening statements for the rapper's sex trafficking trial beginning May 12.
Diddy's defense team was joined by high-profile criminal defense lawyer Mark Geragos. Sources told Fox News Digital that Geragos will assist Combs’ legal team throughout the trial in an unofficial role.
DIDDY TRIAL: RAPPER FACES JURY IN OPINIONATED NY HOMETOWN BID FOR FREEDOM ON SEX TRAFFICKING CHARGES
Sean "Diddy" Court is shown in a sketch from court Monday as jury selection began in his trial on federal charges of sex trafficking and other sex crimes. (Jane Rosenberg)
The prosecution filed a letter to Judge Arun Subramanian on Tuesday calling out Geragos for public statements made about the trial, noting that anybody associated with the defense is not allowed to make statements that could "interfere with a fair trial."
"The need for the Court’s admonishment is necessary given that as recently as three days ago, Mr. Geragos spoke at length about the trial in this case in his podcast called ‘2 Angry Men,’ Mr. Geragos’s podcast with Harvey Levin, the creator of the tabloid news organization TMZ," the prosecution team wrote in the letter obtained by Fox News Digital.
"During the podcast, Mr. Geragos opined on a variety of topics, including characterizing specific pieces of evidence in this case (describing the Government’s use of the Intercontinental Hotel video surveillance as 'character assassination'); the makeup of the prosecution team handling this case (observing that it could ‘look like you’re prosecuting a cause’); and arguments the defense intends to make (noting that the defendant ‘has a violent temper and especially, I think, when you combine it with the drug use, but that isn’t what he’s charged with’). In the podcast, Mr. Geragos advises listeners that he will be back next week to discuss further."
Fox News Digital has reached out to Diddy's team for comment.
WATCH: ATTORNEY MARK GERAGOS WALKS INTO COURT FOR DAY ONE OF DIDDY JURY SELECTION
DIDDY TRIAL: RAPPER FACES JURY IN OPINIONATED NY HOMETOWN BID FOR FREEDOM ON SEX TRAFFICKING CHARGES
A sketch portrays Sean "Diddy" Combs seated before Judge Arun Subramanian in federal court today, Manhattan, NY, Monday, May 5, 2025. (Jane Rosenberg)
Jury selection resumed at 9 a.m. on Tuesday, May 6. For the voir dire process, the jurors are given a list of people and places and asked to note if they recognize any.
Comedian Mike Myers, Diddy's children – Justin and Christian Combs, Aubrey O'Day, actress Lauren London, actor Michael B. Jordan, musician Kid Cudi, Kanye West, singer Michelle Williams, Dawn Richards and Diddy's ex-girlfriend Cassie Ventura were among the names recognized by some of the potential jurors.
While it's unclear why some of the celebrities made this list, USA Today reported there is a scene in Myers' "Austin Powers" that jokes about the disgraced rapper.
Fox News Digital has reached out to Myers' rep for comment.
WATCH ON FOX NATION: WHAT DIDDY DO?
Victor Balladares with Offit Kurman told Fox News Digital that the voir dire process is "crucial for both the defense and prosecution" for identifying potential juror biases.
"Inquiring if jurors recognize certain celebrity names helps determine their exposure to media coverage or personal opinions about individuals who may be involved in the case," Balladares said. "Familiarity with key figures could influence a juror's perspective, consciously or subconsciously. Identifying such connections ensures that selected jurors can evaluate the case based solely on the presented evidence, free from external influences."
"Overall, these targeted questions are designed to assemble a jury capable of delivering a fair and unbiased verdict by thoroughly examining potential prejudices and ensuring that personal experiences or beliefs do not compromise the judicial process," he added.
Diddy's son, Christian Combs, was named during jury questioning. (Samir Hussein)
Diddy's ex-girlfriend, Cassie, filed a sexual abuse suit against Diddy in November 2023, which was settled one day later. (Getty Images)
Fox News legal editor Kerri Urbahn noted that the prosecution's questions to the jurors were to make sure there are no Diddy "superfans," while Diddy's team is looking for the "exact opposite" out of a jury.
"The prosecution is going to be looking for people who feel that wealthy people get away with stuff the average person does not, because that will be part of their framing of their case: that the rich and famous should be held accountable just like everyone else and Diddy is at the top of the list," Urbahn said.
LIKE WHAT YOU’RE READING? CLICK HERE FOR MORE ENTERTAINMENT NEWS
Diddy appeared anxious on the first day of his federal trial and told the judge, "I'm a little nervous today." (Elizabeth Williams)
The proposed list of questions that were asked of the potential jurors included inquiries into their favorite music, how they felt about celebrities and their beliefs regarding partners who cheat.
"Overall, these targeted questions are designed to assemble a jury capable of delivering a fair and unbiased verdict by thoroughly examining potential prejudices and ensuring that personal experiences or beliefs do not compromise the judicial process."
"What kind of music do you like? How often do you listen to music? Do you have an opinion about the hip-hop rap music industry or artists in that genre? If so, please tell us what it is."
"The defendant in this case is a wealthy celebrity. Do you have any opinions regarding wealthy individuals that would affect your ability to serve as a fair and impartial juror in this case? Do you believe that wealthy people get away with things that the less wealthy do not?
"There may be evidence that people cheated on girlfriends or boyfriends with other individuals. Would hearing about that type of evidence affect your ability to serve as a fair and impartial juror in this case?"
CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP FOR THE ENTERTAINMENT NEWSLETTER
Criminal defense lawyer Lauren Johnson-Norris told Fox News Digital that the questions are "strategic and not superficial."
Potential jurors were asked how they felt about celebrities and their beliefs regarding partners who cheat. (Elizabeth Williams via AP)
"Questions about cheating partners or celebrity recognition cut to the core of juror psychology," Johnson-Norris said. "Have they been betrayed? Are they starstruck? Do they think justice bends for the rich? Each answer helps the attorneys read between the lines and strike the people who might already have their minds made up.
Oleg Nekritin, a defense attorney at the Law Offices of Robert J. DeGroot, noted that Diddy's team likely engaged in "mock trials and focus groups" prior to the jury questioning.
"Questions about cheating partners or celebrity recognition cut to the core of juror psychology."
"When a case bears marks of celebrity or notoriety, it is also important for the government to ensure that potential advocates or individuals with preconceived notions and prejudices do not make it on a jury," Nekritin told Fox News Digital. "The more questions you ask, the more likely you are to find out who will not be able to view the case fairly and impartially."
Former felony prosecutor Eric Faddis agreed that jurors' responses could indicate how a jury may view certain evidence or arguments.
Diddy retained Marc Agnifilo and Teny Geragos to lead his defense team. (Rashid Umar Abbasi for Fox News Digital)
"The defense is seeking jurors who do not have delicate sensibilities, jurors who can hear evidence about what the defense may style as ‘sex, drugs, and rock and roll’ without being put off or rushing to judgment," Faddis said. "The prosecution wants jurors who will not be distracted by bright shiny objects or get off track by any circus the defense may bring to trial."
The "Last Night" singer hired Marc Agnifilo to spearhead his legal defense after being arrested in September following a federal indictment. In addition to Agnifilo, the disgraced music mogul retained criminal defense attorney Teny Geragos, the daughter of renowned criminal defense lawyer Mark Geragos.
Fox News' Kirill Clark and Stephanie Giang-Paunon contributed to this report.
Trending
Fox News Entertainment
Get a daily look at the top news in music, movies, television and more in the entertainment industry.
By entering your email and clicking the Subscribe button, you agree to the Fox News Privacy Policy and Terms of Use, and agree to receive content and promotional communications from Fox News. You understand that you can opt-out at any time.